Discussion about this post

User's avatar
William's avatar

"note that the dependence of justice on the existence of some kind of social contract does not mean that justice is entirely mutable or subjective: there is a “justice of nature.”

Hello Jack, I'm glad you wrote on this point and am somewhat critical of DeWitt's writing on this point, that Justice basically just means obedience to the written law of the country, curious of you agree.

https://www.epicureanfriends.com/thread/5282-criticism-of-dewitt-s-interpretation-of-principal-doctrine-5/?postID=41281#post41281

Also curious if you agree that Epicurus recognized a "guilty conscience" as Torquatus seems mentions, or of this was just a minor point for them, perhaps because it was too closely tied to political "honor".

"Justice never cause anyone harm, but on the contrary it always adds some benefit, partly owing to its essentially tranquilizing influence upon the mind...but what can wickedness contribute towards lessening the annoyances of life, commensurate with its effect in increasing them, owing to the burden of a guilty conscience, the penalties of the law and the hatred of one's fellows?" (On Ends, 1.50-51)

1 more comment...

Ready for more?